Showing posts with label Nakba. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Nakba. Show all posts

September 11, 2014

Pro-Israel Group Think

by Diane V. McLoughlin, September 11th, 2014

The highest ideal espoused in Rabbi Shmuel Bloch's argument, 'Unity - It's surreal and frightening'; [South African Jewish Report, Sept 10, 2014], is cohesiveness of group politics rather than questioning the direction, politics and morality of the group in a personal quest for truth. Can good be expected to follow from this premise or is such a stance fraught with risk?

The rabbi reports that 'unity became even stronger and tighter' once Israelis learned the tragic fate of the three Jewish youths who were kidnapped in the occupied West Bank when hitchhiking, presumably back to their respective homes, from a settlement religious school. 

There is an enormous gap the rabbi leaves unexplained regarding how the country went from the crime of the former, to an entire country choosing to wage war: 

 'Then the rockets started falling and Operation “Protective Edge” began...The entire country supported the government and the army with almost universal approval.'

Without questioning, we would not know that tensions began to rise not with the abduction and murders of the three Jewish teens in June, but three weeks before, on Nakba Day, May 15th. The IDF shot and killed two Palestinian teens in cold blood at a demonstration outside of Ofer Prison.  One of the youths was shot in the back.  Both were unarmed, it was in broad daylight and there were many witnesses to these events.

After the three Jewish teens went missing, this gave Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu the excuse he needed to ramp up tensions further by instituting what was the equivalent of a Palestinian Kristalnacht in the occupied West Bank on the pretext of searching for the teens. There was a clear purpose in instigating such provocations. In recent days, Palestinian political leadership of rival political parties Hamas and Fatah signaled their intention to reconcile. Unified, Natenyahu et al could no longer claim that they had no 'partner for peace'.  Peace means the cessation of further ethnic cleansing and colonization of Palestinian land. 


Hundreds of West Bank homes were violently broken into in the middle of the night. IDF soldiers caused gratuitous wanton damage to households; stole money and other valuables; viciously beat people; and arrested hundreds without charge - including many in the Hamas party leadership.  And with this for background, how things devolved becomes far more clear. Rabbi Bloch's timeline of events makes absolutely no sense otherwise.  

Logic

No logical person would ever accept the premise that oppressing the Other could foster greater prospects for peaceful security for oneself.  


There is no logical correllary between a criminal investigation into the kidnappings and murders of three teenagers versus the ultimate crime of aggressive war on a captive civilian population. 

The 1.8 million people of The Gaza Strip have been suffering under an illegal Israeli military occupation for years.  This latest military slaughter caused the deaths of over 500 children alone.  Israel's 'Operation Protective Edge' was instigated by Israel, the violence was wanton, the IDF committed many war crimes, Israeli political leaders openly call for genocide [or the practical equivalent, as seen in Deputy Minister of Defense, Dany Alon's recent inane, amoral tweet:  






The highest ideal is not group cohesiveness.  Cohesiveness is for cowards.  The highest ideal is risking rejection by the group by pointing out the errors of the group's leadership.  

Some of the best blogs [of which there are many]: Mondoweiss; Richard Silverstein.

Organizations: Independent Jewish Voices; Jewish Voices for Peace




July 12, 2014

Owen Jones BBC Question Time on Israel Gaza Conflict - 2012 [2mins]




November 22, 2012

Debate: BBC One 
Question Time on the Israel - Gaza conflict.  
Owen Jones at bat.  

*Fair Use

May 15, 2011

Youtube - Peaceful Nakba Day protesters shot by IDF - Gaza, Palestine - May 15, 2011 - Ken O'Keefe


Taken from 7:30 mins. or so of this 14 min. youtube gets right to the
heart of the events of this peaceful protest, and the IDF's violent response.

March 10, 2010

On the So-called Double Nakba

Diane V. McLoughlin Mar. 10, '10
mcloughlinpost.com

I have been contemplating ideas and questions today put to me by a commenter. I will call him Vlad. Vlad has asked me why I think Palestinian refugees have a right of return to Israel if Jews do not have the right of return to Arab countries. This is an interesting ethical question.

First, I personally cannot comment on whether or not Jews can return to Arab countries they left because I do not know if Jews wish to go back to Arab countries they left, and if they do, whether or not they would be allowed to go back. I think few would want to try living in Arab countries while the oppression of Palestinians by Israel continues. But I could be wrong. There is a long-standing Jewish community in Iran that is apparently content where it is. So that is interesting.

If Jews were forcefully expelled that was wrong. If Jews were expelled without being able to take with them the full value of their possessions and holdings then this is an issue for legal consideration and compensation.

But, I believe that there is a fallacy in the linking of the expulsion of Palestinians from their homes in Israel, known as the Nakba ('catastrophe') to expulsion of Jews in Arab countries. No country should be above the law. All crimes suffered by victims ought to call for redress. We cannot say a crime was committed to me, therefore I intend to also commit similar crimes to people who had nothing to do with what happened to me.

It is factually false to imply that 'far greater' numbers of Jews were expelled by Arab countries than were Palestinians expelled by Israel, as Vlad supposes. Between 800,000 and one million Jews departed from Arab lands - some were expelled. Some were compelled. But importantly, some were enticed by Zionist organizations.Zionists wanted Jews to inhabit Palestine. Some Zionists were fanatical zealots. They had their reasons. Jews have long experience with discrimination and oppression, to varying degrees, from place to place, and from time to time. But Zionists could have saved some Jews from the Germans and didn't. Zionists could have helped some Jews escape to countries such as Britain. But didn't. 'One cow in Palestine is worth more than all the Jews in Poland.' So believed one Zionist fanatic. (See: http://www.jewsagainstzionism.com/antisemitism/holocaust/index.cfm)

Between 650,000 to 750,000 Palestinians were expelled by force and through the use of terrorism, by Israel. Some Arab countries reacted to the plight of the Palestinians by reacting in kind toward their native Jewish citizens. I believe that any expulsion, any discrimination, is wrong.

The argument by Israel that Palestinians should not have the right of return, a right which is recognized under international law, is weakened through actions by Israel herself. Israeli courts have granted Jews who lost control of properties in Jerusalem pre-1948 the right to take them back from Palestinians. As rights activists point out, this nullifies the case Israel tries to make that Palestinians who were expelled from their properties don't have the right to get it back. Another argument Israel tries to make is that all of this is ancient history; that current land ownership is carved in stone. The recent expulsions of Palestinian families from homes in Jerusalem they lived in for fifty years to give back to former Jewish owners completely nullifies Israel's argument that Palestinians do not have the right to take back what is theirs as well. (See: http://www.nytimes.com/2010/03/10/world/middleeast/10jerusalem.html?hpw )

Vlad insists that we should only focus on the woeful treatment of Palestinian refugees in places such as Lebanon, and that under no circumstances ought we to examine the woeful treatment of Palestinians either in Israel proper, the West Bank or the Gaza Strip, because he believes the former is far worse off than the latter.

Vlad implies, without coming right out with it, that not only is such criticism of Israel verbotten, but that it is racist to criticize Israel's racist oppression of the Palestinians.

What I would grant Vlad is the fact that he may well not know the true plight of Palestinians under Israel's boot. It is common knowledge that most Israelis themselves have little idea what their country is doing to the Palestinians either in the West Bank or the Gaza Strip. But it seems to me that the German people did not come off too well in the court of world opinion when they claimed they did not know what their government was doing to the Jews, Gypsies, political opponents and activists, Gays, the Polish, physically and mentally handicapped, and whoever else wasn't approved of or got in the Nazi juggernaut's way of its maniacal aims.

Under Israel's 1992 Law of Political Parties, 'any party platform that challenges the Jewish character of the state, that for example calls for full and complete equality between Jews and Arabs in a state for all its citizens, can be disqualified, as lists have been in the past.' (See: http://www.arabhra.org/hra/SecondaryArticles/SecondaryArticlePage.aspx?SecondaryArticle=1499 )

Another example of discrimination against Arab-Israeli citizens: 'The government categorises the country into different zones and awards different statuses and benefits to different towns. For instance, it denotes certain areas national development areas, which then makes them eligible to receive benefits including special tax incentives for industry, educational programmes, and housing incentives. These areas are supposed to be determined according to socio-economic criteria. Yet the zones are drawn to include a disproportionate number of Jewish localities rather than Palestinian Arab ones. For example, in the 1998 classification, out of the 429 localities accorded Development Area A status, only 4 were Arab, despite the fact that Arab towns and villages are consistently at the bottom of the socio-economic scale. The zoning was used to exclude the vast majority of the Palestinian Arab minority from these benefits.'

Doing the math, Arab-Israelis account for approximately 20 percent of Israel's population. So, a fairer distribution of pubic services would find 86 Arab-Israeli localities accorded Development Area A status - not 4.

'In the private sector employers openly discriminate against Arab-Israeli workers.'
(scroll to pg. 849: http://docs.google.com/viewer?a=v&q=cache:l_OZngtzJsAJ:www.law.nyu.edu/ecm_dlv2/groups/public/%40nyu_law_website__journals__journal_of_international_law_and_politics/documents/documents/ecm_pro_059603.pdf+list+discriminatory+policies+against+Arab-Israeli+citizens&hl=en&gl=ca&pid=bl&srcid=ADGEESj8xOHWDD8SWXfGFg2Xe0VScerMq4djA95o36e5LEq9Cp4zFfZdOC9SF2V5ZkXd-xf64FxAqZfNNxY7KhwvX-dNd15Y5MfODmbG18upS-HvU6b7ZmUkAjjqb2iniXq3x8f_myMv&sig=AHIEtbRE7wI4I17VWsd2yjfA04iQ1LNoWg

(Srry for that ridiculously long link.)

Another way Israeli-Arabs are discriminated against is in Israel's racist marriage laws. 'The naturalization law of December 2003, which bars Palestinians from the occupied territories from obtaining any residency status or citizenship in Israel through marriage to an Israeli citizen, thereby preventing them from living in Israel with their spouses. Heavily criticized by Israeli and international human rights groups, the law is aimed exclusively against Israel's Palestinian minority, whose members often marry across the Green Line.' (http://www.thirdworldtraveler.com/Israel/FascismNeedsEnemy_Israel.html)

So I hope the above primer has been of some help to Vlad.  It doesn't really capture the essence of the grinding oppression Palestinians are forced to endure. But maybe it might encourage him, support him, really, in continuing to ask probing questions and to seek out the truth for himself.